HackModford
Active Member
- Joined
- Oct 2, 2007
- Messages
- 813
- Age
- 33
I like the idea and would be perfectly happy if it was android.
Pandora Should Move To Android
- Thread starter craigix
- Start date
- Joined
- Dec 8, 2005
- Messages
- 6,603
- Age
- 40
- Location
- UK
- Website
- pokeparadox.itch.io
- WEBSITE
- https://github.com/pokeparadox
- YOUTUBE
- pokeparadox
I have no issue if Android compatibility is bolted onto our OS... so you can access the Android apps and run them, but to switch to Android completely is just silly.Exophase said:
Last edited by a moderator:
craigix said:
exclusively move to? maybe not.
but having Android as a supported OS can't hurt.
as for getting commercial software & games, getting more than 1000 devices out there might help a lot
I got to try barzoule's Pandora at @Party2010 and we discussed making games, the market is still much too small to support pandora-exclusive commercial projects but I'm planning on doing Pandora ports of my games as they're developed under Linux anyway.
I just need my device to test
Last edited by a moderator:
Caine
Hardcore Member
Summary so far: (no|yes|ok, but only as an option)*Jourdy288 said:Hmmm.. Fifteen pages... I hate to say this, but TL
Last edited by a moderator:
Eniko
Raving Python fangirl
There are a few people who don't agree with this view, you know.trix said:
Last edited by a moderator:
yodaofborg
Assimilated you will be!
Eniko said:
Yeah, but their posts got buried so fast by those of us thinking the above, that nobody saw em!
Last edited by a moderator:
sebt3
homebrew player (P. & C.)
The link sound like they are using custom API / interfaces. IMHO this is line I draw to take apart what is a simple fork (that will/may be merge back) and something that isn't linux anymore.Exophase said:
When I sugested the idea to use Stuckie extention system, I was thinking about : chroot the whole android image, provide device interface (a few mknod) and force it to use second framebuffer.
But as android is using a custom framebuffer API, that won't work. At least without a large job on the base Android libs. At this point, you're not packaging, you are porting from a plateform to an other.
What I was suggesting was feasible in a reasonable time-frame for an high-level hacker (that's not me, obviously), but with the API changes the timeframe is way less reasonable.
and knowing that the beagleboard team still have no framebuffer for android is a clear indication that the changes are not obvious at all'.
Last edited by a moderator:
Exophase
Nothing good will ever come of Exophase.
sebt3 said:
To me I think it qualifies as "Linux" so long as the base APIs, syscalls, driver model, etc are still available. I don't know if it's the case on Android, that they're using custom new interfaces on top of everything, or if they have stripped out and replaced things. I'm not trying to force a semantic argument on this, the reason why I think this is relevant is because it dictates whether or not Linux things can be ported to it.
Can you link me to any kind of writeup of Android's framebuffer API? I'm wondering if an emulation device is not possible. You seem to be talking about allowing Android to be ran within a vanilla Linux build like what we currently have. I'm thinking more the opposite, going to an Android that's compatible with current Pandora applications as a Linux substitute (obviously won't work for anything relying on X, but apps using SDL or fbdev/OSS/ALSA/etc straight could).
I'm concerned about any OS options, particularly ones that gain any fair amount of traction, that cause a fundamental software compatibility split. I don't like knowing that, even optionally, the already small Pandora userbase might not have routine access to the same app pool. People will dual boot, but inevitably a lot of them will end up sticking with whatever they use the most, because switching OSes is a pain. So if compatibility isn't there I don't think both should be supported/endorsed options.
Last edited by a moderator:
puppydee
Linux Virgin!
I don't really mind either way but I might be selling my pandora anyhow since I might be needing some cash for real life type of things, it's complicated
sebt3
homebrew player (P. & C.)
Nothing outside the register link above. I didn't knew before reading this article.Exophase said:
In fact the last time I checked android, I discovered that they were using their own libc (containing their own threading implementation) , I was gone like "bulls**t, what we needed the most is a 4th opensource libc implementation for the linux kernel, yeahh". So you could guess my knowledge of the actual plateform...
For the rest we basically agree, I was thinking about using our current kernel as writing kernel drivers is not the easiest task on earth.
Last edited by a moderator:
xopher
Member
When I first read this it was 2 pages deep. It seemed like an intelligent pondering. Now I am wondering if Craig has trolled you all while on break from the assembly line. :unsure: Then again I haven't read much of the other 14 pages of postings, probably just my ignorance appearing in public. Good thing I wear pants.
Android Blog regarding app-removal.
I... Well... And...
Please don't.
Over-The-Air; centralized; protection!; removal of 'malicious' software... This is just pure evil, even more pure than this interesting ED-pic that's floating around here somewhere.
I... Well... And...
Please don't.
SNESFAN
Retro game fanatic
I would run android as the main OS if it was offered, it already has all the software I could ever want for a handheld. The one thing my android phones are missing are gaming controls and a keyboard.
I would literally be beside myself in happiness if the latest version of android (AOSP 2.2 froyo) and the market were gotten to run on the pandora.
if there's a dev fund directly related to this project, point me in that direction
I would literally be beside myself in happiness if the latest version of android (AOSP 2.2 froyo) and the market were gotten to run on the pandora.
if there's a dev fund directly related to this project, point me in that direction
DynaMight
Member
If anyone wants to play with Android, go ahead: http://developer.android.com/guide/developing/tools/emulator.html You wont get the Market/Google Maps etc though, but you can install apps by their APK's
Best way to proceed is to find out if there are drivers already available for Pandoras hardware. The Motorola Milestone used the OMAP3530 A8 Cortex and full specs can be found here: http://and-developers.com/motorola_milestone:device_information
Best way to proceed is to find out if there are drivers already available for Pandoras hardware. The Motorola Milestone used the OMAP3530 A8 Cortex and full specs can be found here: http://and-developers.com/motorola_milestone:device_information
Exophase
Nothing good will ever come of Exophase.
sebt3 said:
I think not too many new drivers would have to be ported, since there are already OMAP3 Android devices. It would be helpful if something was using the same wifi chip too, in fact very helpful as I think this could a long way towards ironing out remaining wifi software issues. Control drivers, including nub would be on the table no matter what.. and the audio driver, since it's not a standard twl4030 setup. I wonder what kind of audio system Android uses, and if it'd maybe have benefits over what we're using now too (or drawbacks).
Actually, it's strange that Beagleboard isn't ahead of the curve given Droid etc, is there something going on that's not requiring them to share all their hardware support code? Are drivers ending up in userspace?
Last edited by a moderator:
