W
WhiteBat
Guest
Evil, could you post some bigger pictures? maybe that would help since the little pics are pixely.
I think the font looks fine really. BT doesn't bug me that much, it's one of those things that I won't even care about when I get my Pandora. I really like the 'First Batch', so all in all it looks good and I don't think anyone can complain.EvilDragon said:Well, some things on the silk:
The BT logo can't be used. Yes, membership is free - but to put the logo as member onto a device, you need to pay 3000 EUR.
I couldn't find any real good replacement for it. There was one nice looking similar to the BT one at the thread, but that was TOO similar... this could also end up somebody sueing us.
The First Batch text is there (and no box with a 1 or whatever), since it won the poll. Even Craig and Michael voted for the box with the 1, however, we kept it because the Pandora is a community device and the community decided with a poll.
I have no idea why the designs shouldn't be, all letters an numbers are the same font (and we have to use a ROYALTY FREE font, we can't just use any font we like...)
EvilDragon said:Well, some things on the silk:
The BT logo can't be used. Yes, membership is free - but to put the logo as member onto a device, you need to pay 3000 EUR.
I couldn't find any real good replacement for it. There was one nice looking similar to the BT one at the thread, but that was TOO similar... this could also end up somebody sueing us.
The First Batch text is there (and no box with a 1 or whatever), since it won the poll. Even Craig and Michael voted for the box with the 1, however, we kept it because the Pandora is a community device and the community decided with a poll.
I have no idea why the designs shouldn't be, all letters an numbers are the same font (and we have to use a ROYALTY FREE font, we can't just use any font we like...)
Not to detract from your decision, but I don't really think that poll was very indicative of the community. Very low voting, and I'm pretty sure someone mentioned that a large number of fake accounts were created for the purpose of skewing the results. The 1-over-box was probably close enough that you could have chosen it for personal reasons and not many people would have complained.EvilDragon said:The First Batch text is there (and no box with a 1 or whatever), since it won the poll. Even Craig and Michael voted for the box with the 1, however, we kept it because the Pandora is a community device and the community decided with a poll.
Dead1nside said:I'm really not trying to diminish your huge efforts but I just don't think it looks good at all.
I am also aware that these things are subjective and a matter of taste.
What with the |0|0| on the A/V port?
If you're going to choose the filled SD card icons, why not choose the filled BT icon?
The one you've chosen seems slightly too large.
The wireless icon isn't my favourite either, the on with an antenna emitting the radio waves is more pleasing.
I could live with everything but the top-left hand side's icons - there's just something about that cluster that looks wrong.
As for royalty free fonts, how about the Liberation family from Red Hat?
There were some fake accounts, but only a few, and it won by more than 20 votes.WizardStan said:Not to detract from your decision, but I don't really think that poll was very indicative of the community. Very low voting, and I'm pretty sure someone mentioned that a large number of fake accounts were created for the purpose of skewing the results. The 1-over-box was probably close enough that you could have chosen it for personal reasons and not many people would have complained.EvilDragon said:The First Batch text is there (and no box with a 1 or whatever), since it won the poll. Even Craig and Michael voted for the box with the 1, however, we kept it because the Pandora is a community device and the community decided with a poll.
I respectfully disagree. The community has been behind this project from the beginning and if they have opinions about the design, they should be expressed. Now it's up to OP to decide if anything the community questions has merit and would require a change. They've already stated previously that the silk screening is a quick process so it shouldn't be an issue anyway since we're still a little while away from the end of the month. I mean, let's be honest, once we get the bad boy, all eyes will be on the screen not on the case. However, it's the coolness factor of showing it off to your friends and family causing them to buy one from the second batch that is what you really want. You don't want it to look like it was just thrown together with icons here, text here, and a mixture of text & icons over there.Mjlink said:To the Devs: Good job! Thanks for the update.
To the Sally's bitching about BT & fonts & any other concern over this silkscreening nonsense: wash your silks & save the bandwidth.
Otherwise: It'll be two more months.
/rant
Link
PS if you can't match the peg to the hole...
EvilDragon said:The First Batch text is there (and no box with a 1 or whatever), since it won the poll. Even Craig and Michael voted for the box with the 1, however, we kept it because the Pandora is a community device and the community decided with a poll.
fretfrenzy182 said:Everyone will never agree on one design so there is little point arguing. Regardless of absolute authenticity, the poll showed what they put on the case. on a slightly unrelated note, would there be any real/serious consequences of putting the "official" bluetooth logo on the device. Not a question of law, a question of consequence and or chances of getting reprimanded.
God Ginrai said:fretfrenzy182 said:Everyone will never agree on one design so there is little point arguing. Regardless of absolute authenticity, the poll showed what they put on the case. on a slightly unrelated note, would there be any real/serious consequences of putting the "official" bluetooth logo on the device. Not a question of law, a question of consequence and or chances of getting reprimanded.
Either a very large fine or maybe even a lawsuit. Definitely not something to chance.
-God Ginrai
There probably is a small department of the Bluetooth Illuminati who look out for unlicensed devices, and now that they are in talks with OP, they will definitely be watching. They can't take any chances with stuff like that, especially if they're hoping to sell a lot more units in the future.fretfrenzy182 said:God Ginrai said:fretfrenzy182 said:Everyone will never agree on one design so there is little point arguing. Regardless of absolute authenticity, the poll showed what they put on the case. on a slightly unrelated note, would there be any real/serious consequences of putting the "official" bluetooth logo on the device. Not a question of law, a question of consequence and or chances of getting reprimanded.
Either a very large fine or maybe even a lawsuit. Definitely not something to chance.
-God Ginrai
Im not advocating this in any way im just curious. I guess to re-phrase my question, who's gonna know?
Considering that they're hoping to produce numbers upwards of 50'000 to 100'000 (although I'm sure they'd love to sell more if the demand appears), I'm pretty sure they're hoping that everyone will know. It only takes the one right person to see it to make everything go wrong, so why take that chance at all?fretfrenzy182 said:Im not advocating this in any way im just curious. I guess to re-phrase my question, who's gonna know?