WizardStan said:
I did and I'm not badgering. Grench said he had a fully functional iPod, complete with colour screen, that is only being used as an external hard drive. A solution was presented that would allow him to continue using it exactly as he has been, and regain the MP3 features. You then summarily dismissed the solution as "that's not the point." Fine, if you get a broken hard-drive-only one, the MP3 playback is pretty useless, but Grench has one that supposedly works perfectly. By intentionally not taking advantage of the key feature of the device, it is a waste, not unlike (from my earlier analogy) using the Pandora only for checking email.
I already own and use a superior MP3 player (Tapwave Zodiac). The iPod's limited functionality does not come close to replacing it.
The 80GB iPod was free/gift. Yes it -can- be used for more, but it's greatest utility to me is as a USB powered 80GB thumb drive. My comment around it was more to do with the fact that it does indeed work with x86 and AMD64 Linux as a very good mass storage device. It may seem criminal to those of you who own, use and like your iPod - don't really care. It is doing the task that I have assigned it.
As for using a Pandora for email - I fully intend to use mine as a PDA, email, web surfing and MP3 machine. Yes, I realize it isn't it's 'proper use'. However, as I have found out with the Zodiac, game machines tend to have a -lot- better controls than non-game machines. I like having solid controls and broad functionality. Will I play games on it? Occasionally. Do I see games as it's #1 purpose for me? No.
The #1 expansion option I wish we could get for the Pandora? SDXC drivers. That would require OpenPandora to license the SDXC spec - which would be wise to do if the 2nd batch is looking large. They could then sell the software upgrade back to the rest of us as well as showing improved function for the 2nd batch without making hardware changes (just a thought guys).
Back to docking & expansion stations and the like...
We know that the Pandora expansion plug on the back has composite, svideo, audio in, audio out and UART access. What else is in there?
From what it looks like, whatever gets built (if anything) for a dock would have to plug into both the Pandora expansion plug and the USB-A connectors.
The USB-A is not going to give enough power to run the dock, so it would either need to be self-powered OR tap into the Pandora's main battery. Tapping into the main battery wouldn't be difficult, but we do not know if there is enough head room between the Pandora's max draw and it's 3.25A discharge cap (Per Mweston above). In fact, I don't think we would want the combined Pandora and expansion load to exceed 3.0A max.
Using a 2nd Pandora battery in the expansion - dedicated to the expansion would have some benefits. Common battery so that if you're using your Pandora but not the expansion, you could swap them out when your main runs down. The disadvantage is that it would dictate that the expansion be a brick.
The Pandora's capabilities are already pretty big. It is hard to justify a mobile expansion case without it including some pretty fancy stuff in it. Just a few extra USB ports isn't going to cut it. There are plenty of cheap USB hubs out there. If your intentions are to use it for a big mouse, big keyboard and other non-portable gear - you're probably going to be doing this at a desk with AC power anyway. I have a folding bluetooth keyboard and a credit-card sized bluetooth mouse - both battery operated. So... USB isnt' the only option in these.
So, how big is too big for an expansion if it's intended use is mobile? What could be crammed into this space to justify the development costs? What is the 'must have' feature? For mobile, my #1 would be more SDHC(SDXC?) storage slots - even if they're on a USB controller. #2 would be a 3" or so low-range woofer - can't really call a 3" speaker a sub even though HP and Lenovo do. I'm sure that the Pandora screen speakers are as nice as they get for the space they have, but a bigger cone for reinforcement would be kind of cool.
If it were envisioned as a non-portable docking station, what would need to be on it? In this case 3-7 USB ports, video out with a VGA translation or DVI or HDMI (yes, converted signal from the svideo), audio in/out, power connector, and everything else that the Pandora specific port has to offer. Would this include breaking the UART out into an RS-232? Is there anything else to be had through there? Maybe throw in another few SDHC card slots or a couple of 18in1 (or whatever) multi-card readers, an IRDA (for remotes), two 10/100/1000 hard wired ethernet ports (to use a Pandora as a router/firewall) just for good measure. All of the above would be -slow- since it would be limited to what can move in/out of the device through the available ports.
Fun stuff.