Fat Agnus said:
I remember people saying/writing the same thing about sales based on merit in regards to OS/2, Amiga, Betamax, and the myriad of handheld gaming systems (lynx, game gear, neogeo pocket) that got its ass handed to them by the inferior B&W gameboy.
You're equating sales numbers to success, which is only part of the picture. I think you'll have a hard time convincing some people here that the Amiga wasn't successful. True, the Amiga never had a significant percentage of the home computer market. But there were (and still are) a lot of people who swear by the hardware and support the software, many years after they've discontinued production.
That is how you determine success. Quality is far more important than quantity.
The designers don't need to sell tens of millions of Pandoras to make money, and the community doesn't need tens of millions of users to be successful. GPH only sold ~ 50k GP2Xs, and that was certainly a success. The GP2X community has the best developers and the most active and intelligent forums (believe it or not). Pandora isn't even commercially available yet and we already have the biggest homebrew handheld developers working on ports and original software.
Pandora will sell itself to intelligent users who understand what it is and what it can do. In these circumstances, any customer you have to work hard to win over isn't worth having. The sort of people who base all their purchasing decisions on marketing and advertising aren't going to add anything to the community.
I think at the time the Amiga and ST did have a nice chunk of the market, of course when windows 95 came out the competition had all been wiped out anyway.
Depending on where you look the total worldwide Amigas sold is between 5.5-8 million units with the majority of those sold between 1989-1992 also the majority of those were sold in Europe which is probably why you rate the % lower, the total Amigas sold in the US is between 700K-800K only half what the UK sold alone. (Figures for ST suggest around 6 million units)
I think some people rate the success of a platform either of units sold, or by software titles available, I think in the case of the Amiga and ST both were very successful with the Amiga having 5000 games and i would Imagine the ST not being too far behind.
Both companies Atari and Commodore were making money on these platforms, it was later ventures what killed them off (Say Jaguar/Lynx and CDTV/CD32)...
And Fat Agnus you haven't got a clue even listing Amiga next to OS/2 / Betamax.....sales were based on its being the best computer out there with the best specs and best games...you contradicted yourself because the B&W Gameboy sold on merit Nintendo et all.