A_SN said:
To me, the ideal menu would take most concepts from computer OS GUIs. You would have a desktop, with shortcuts to your favourite stuff on it, for quick access to what you like best, and folders and mounted folders, so you could browse the filesystem. Files would be recognized based on their extension, just like in any OS GUI, for instance a .jpg would be opened with the built-in image viewer, a program would be executed, etc. Also, when a program would crash, the menu would report it with a dialog box and the return value (instead of leaving you with nothing running like the default gp2x menu) and when a program would quit/crash, you would naturally find the menu as you left it, with windows opened as they were, etc, etc.
Well that sounds like a complete OS. Gmenu2X is only a menu shell or frontend that basically just launches apps with some script running abilities, it doesn't replace the OS at all. What you describe would be pretty awkward to use navigating with a d-pad/stick as well. Computers use mice for navigation, that makes a big difference. Gmenu is pretty fast to use just to launch apps on what we have now.
No that's not a bloody complete OS. Learn what an OS is. That's just the same fucking kind of thing as gmenu2x, except with a different approach, ergonomy wise. And it doesn't have to be any bad for dpad+buttons navigation, it can be made to be easily browsable with those, it doesn't *have* to be exactly like a regular PC GUI.
Here's what I'm trying to say in terms you people can understand :
-FS browsing FTW, hierarchy-deprived launcher FTL
-Action depending on file-type FTW
-A kind of desktop to be used as a quick access to favourite stuff FTW
-Basing yourself on well-tried and familiar 20+ year old concepts FTW, wildely experimenting with bad ergonomical concepts FTL
I agree. A desktop environment (that's what it's called) would be awesome on this. I nominate KDE, as it's one of the most powerful. Have you taken a look at Konqueror? It does everything: FTP, web browsing, file managing, searching, craploads of other stuff, and more. Try using some other program to use an FTP server like a normal folder.
Errr, yes, but what I'm talking about isn't exactly a desktop environment
. And Konqueror isn't the only piece of software that treats a FTP folder as a folder, you should have a look at Microsoft Windows
I've never been able to do that on Windows.