see that is problematic to me. they hyped it a lot and I think most of the criticism stems from the overhyping of a game that turned out to be like a childrens game instead of a worthy DK successor.
I just finished the main campaign of D2, and I must admit that not only I felt at home with this game, but it is superior in many ways to DK !!
I'll never be able to go back to DK after seeing how damn incredibly smart the workers are in D2 !! Despite how much work I gave to them, they always knew when to change priority... I never lost a dying unit like happened constantly in both DK games, because workers always came in time to bring the corpse to bed !! And the same for constructing traps and all... I'm without words... for the entire campaign I had the sensation they where actually reading my mind !! After selecting something "urgent" to dig or whatever, in DK I always had to throw some worker there, but not in this game, because they were always doing the right thing at the right time !! Damn, I never even slapped them, they didn't deserved that at all !!
Also I think that the impression I had at the beginning, about the "children game" was because of the "Harry Potter"-like soundtrack and the narrator... that can become a little boring sometimes, but it does a lot of puns that maybe "children" can not understand...
I'm a slow player, I need to construct and upgrade everything before attacking, and this game is great for this type of play, there's also a "timed" mission where you are warned that if you don't kill some people in time, they will crush you with a combined army... and still I survived the fight and the game continued... sooo coool
It is just missing first person view from DK, but mainly all the rest is there, heavily upgraded, especially the AI ... well, maybe the game is a little short (the same fault as War for the Overworld), and maybe a little too easy, but I happily got all the DLCs...
now that I played it, it is even more difficult for me to understand all the criticism I see around