I'm glad I posted this.. a lot of interesting histories and thoughts coming out
Theres definately an attachment/fondness for your firest systems, regardless of what they were. (ie: You could be a kid now and your first machine be a 2600 you stumble across, and you'd still love it.) But it is interesting to see peoples thoughts on going back to older machines _now_, that were before their time _then_, for instance.
It does bring up issues like .. it is often felt that 3d ages poorer than 2d; ie: 3d games on DOS or the Saturn or even early PSX .. it is often said if yo didn't love the game then, it is hard to love them now, but for 2d we are much more forgiving.
I'm still a fan of text adventures (and it makes my heart glow knowing people are still writing them, yay for Inform/etc); I have a great fondness for a vast array of machines since they were all in my time (Vic 20 and up), but I do love discovering great gems ... my family mostly owned the computer style machines (Vic 20, Atari ST) and not games consoles (never had a NES, picked up my own SNES not all that long ago, never had a Genesis/MegaDrive.) Myself, being a handheld/mobile coder I've obsessed over mobiles, so I picked up a Turbo Grafx Express for instance.
So for me, the GP32 helped me discover a lot through emulation .. GPengine ftw! As an emu author I've learned insane amounts of detail over some specific machines, but I code more than I play.. so I have found ebay and emulation to be invaluvable in discovering the gems of the past that we didn't have available or couldn';t afford at the time. (I mean, for your 'first platform', you likely only had a handful of bought games right? No one had 1000 SNES games like they 'could have' now..)
Now, while I argue old movies (black and white say) are perfectly fine, even I find some old games just too brutal to deal with .. either a brutal UI that was forgivable once, or just bad use of artwork. Its "always about gameplay", but even sometimes, the graphcis can be _so bad_ that you can't forgive them anymore. Funny that.
For UI .. I was a big fan of RTS in the Dune 2 through Starcraft days, though I find it too clickhappy now (Supreme Commander, how I wish I coudl enjoy thee... ) but going back now .. I really loved DOS based 'Z' back in the day, for it had some really interesting design decisions. But it lacks the usual RTS UI keystrokes .. no unit grouping, no select group by hitting a number, and certainly nothing like Total Annihilations awesome waypoint system. So I find old RTS... just unplayable,m until they hit a certain level. Weird, and a shamre, but true. Theres a 'threshold' even despire nostalgia
... or maybe not .. Wing Commander is pretty nasty graphicly, and yet it is still so damned awesome.
I still love me my Vic 20, and of _course_ pretty damned much everythign on the 2600 and ST (my bitches), and I have really grown to adore the Turbo Grafx, with some great gems on the Genesis and SNES ...
I don't think this all came out right, but .. rejoice brothers, we all love our retro games!
jeff