Well im going for neither, as both are far too big to be called properly portable for my liking. I think they have both missed the point
For the time being i'm sticking with a good ole nintendo SP withflash cart.
Now that is portable gaming, fits snugly in the pocket of my jeans , with all my games that i want to play on 1 cart (in the device
), and the screen nicely protected. When i go out the house i need only grab the device and shove it in my pocket. One of the reasons i don't use my gp32 apart from when i go away is because if im not wearing a jacket or a bag with deep pockets theres no point in taking it out with me.
Which one you go for will down to own personal prefernece, Mine being portability and durability
... and because of this there will probably be a never ending barrage of arguments over the two.
Personally i see them both offering 2 different experices, pick up and play short burst of fun VS serious ps2 gaming and movies.
Hence out of the current two if i were to get one.. im swayed slightly more towards the DS , the dual screen, have read some intersting items on the potential ideas that the second screen could be used for, pda apps, rts, a control panel, theres a ton of things it could be used for, also the carts are dead tiny so you could actually fit them in your wallet as i do with my SD and smartmedia cards. I don't but the games just look more fun, simple pick up and play, which are ideal for short journeys.
PSP well lush gfx, some great games coming out (but are many of them i can play have a quick 10 minute blast?), looks lovely, be brilliant for watching films whichj i see as big plus but... protecting the screen from scratches is a big downer, if only they had added some sort of plastic flip to close over the screen when not in use. By a case well just adds to the size, and doesn't stop scratching either. PLus i don't think the nice shiny black plastic (although it looks damn lush) is rather prone to greasu finger prints, great for good looking hifi equipment not so great for something thats is meant to be used in your hands! Also what do you do with all the discs, they might be small but i knwo what a pain in the ass it is picking/ choossing 4/5 mini discs and then having to find a pocket to tisk them all in and make sure i don't leave em anywhere.. the more you have to carry the more you have to lose
I would love one for the movie capabilites as the screen is bloody lovely but the portability issues, it doens't look like it would survive too many knocks.
But like i said both are two bulky so for the time being i will wait for the GBA SP 2 which may be released by the end of the year. Hopefully that will be again a flip screen and same size as an sp, if its got a decent battery life then i'm sold