Fishbong said:
I also like DS9 better than any other Star Trek show, however it can't beat Firefly.
Joss Whedon? Really?
Is it anything like the film? I thought that was terrible.
At the end of the day, with DS9 you get a sophisticated sci-fi themed soap-opera/drama series. Not only does it draw from the rich and well developed Star Trek universe, but effectively encompasses the story of entire societies.
From the beginning, the show is catapulted far above any other Star Trek because the various races and characters are in a constant balance of conflict and cooperation.
DS9 depicts an entire war, with all the politics and unpredictable turns you would expect. This includes the prelude and triggering conditions, and the compromises, ethical challenges, and difficult decisions faced on both sides.
The only mistake they made was occasionally falling back on self contained episodes, but this was a move on the part of the studio to keep bringing in new viewers. I remember the opposite happened with Farscape, where episodes became hard to penetrate if you hadn't been following it.
The only sci-fi show I know of with the same breadth and sophistication as DS9 is Babylon 5, but I never got into that. The story goes that Paramount ripped off B5 in creating DS9, but that doesn't make it any less enjoyable. As much as I've tried, I just couldn't get into B5 at all... I might try again.