'Mithrildor' said:
QUOTE
Do they need FCC and CE certification to make the keypad? huh.gif
The whole thing with prototype battery and prototype keypad has to be tested I guess.
Yes, but I don't think that the keypad will be affected by the CE or FCC at all - I don't see why the keymat will cause the Pandora to fail the test, unless Craig knows something we don't.
h34r:
For the same reason the case could make the test fail I guess.
Look at it not from our POV, or the POV of OpenPandora, but the POV of the CE tester and/or the governing body who specifies that CE testing needs to be done and what that entails.
How "safe" is it, from the POV of the testing body, to accept an unfinished product with 1 or more missing pieces and the assurances of the manufacturer that "there's nothing in the missing parts that will affect the CE test"? forget that we're talking about a rubber keymat and some transparent piping here, to my mind the very concept of passing a product through any sort of CE testing would seem to be to pass IT through the testing procedure, not "most of it".
I could be wrong, but typically in my experience beurocracy has a way of wanting to be precise, and of wanting to approve only what it's actually seen rather than somehting "very closely akin to" what has been seen. So to me it seems likely that CE and/or FCC testing will need to be done on a pretty close to final Pandora.
More specifically, the keymat. How could it cause soemthing to fail? Well, it's a bunch of rubber keys with some electically-conducting contacts to short the relevant parts of the board when pressed. That's how the board can tell what key is being pressed. What happens if there's a problem with the board such that when you press "Q" it shorts out the battery terminal? You arne't going to know if you don't have a keymat... and if you test with a keymat that's not from the final mold WITH the hardened top, you aren't necessarily going to be experiencing the behaviour of the final keymat. Maybe the prototype will short out the battery on the !Q" letter but a final keymat won't (it's EVER so slightly different, so it's the "W" key that shorts your battery out in a fraction of a second, blowing your hand off in the process).
These are not likely scenarios - but then, testing isn't about what you expect to happen - it's about trying to ensure the unexpected DOESN'T happen, from a disinterested professional 3rd party. No-one will pay to test a unit they expect to fail (no-one in their right minds, anyway) but that doesn't mean we can just stop testing as "a waste of time". IMHO.
Ta.